We spoke of the distinction between peaceful demonstrating and non-peaceful demonstrations. its seems, according to the class body, to be some difference as to what peaceful means. it also seem to lack an ideal as to what it means to protest. Some seem to think that protesting is OK as long as the police give it its thumbs up. I am at odds with this view, however, it must be pointed out I’ve never been part of a physical protest, at least not in the true sense . It is useful to me to once again to go back to my early years growing up in Belfast, Northern Ireland, where a protest was always cooking in the works somewhere. The police were a different thing back then, they were regular army soldiers. Many of these protests usually disintegrated into a full-scale riot. These riot/protests were planned with the riot in mind. Piles of projectiles, from bricks to the Molotov cocktail would magically appear out of the adjacent alleys to be flung at the opposition. The British soldiers were often the recipient of these projectiles and I was baffled that they just stood there and took this abuse with bricks and flames spilling around them, but most startling was the insults and hateful venom spit at them. I could never understand that, the words seem to come from a place I didn’t know. Here is the point, the authorities were responsible for keeping the peace and that meant keeping the warring parties apart and prevent bloodshed often at their own peril. Sure there were times when the soldiers ranks broke, but I would have to say from my anecdotal viewpoint the soldiers had the best of intentions. This same hands off approach is still used to this day in Northern Ireland, much to the dismay of the outsider.
Switching over to recent events in NYC at the Occupy Wall Street protests, it seem once again the heavy hand of the police are at work to silence the protester and label them as anarchists or something. There has been several cases where protesters have been maced and pepper sprayed, because they were not following the instructions of the police and supposedly endangering public safety. the NYPD spokesperson pointed to cherry picked images to justify there actions, but a subsequent investigation by the NY times has discovered other images that relay the exact opposite. The images show the police actively reaching over the barrier they just constructed and pulled several protesters over the barrier to the ground in a most aggressive manner. hmm, why the big difference here? It seems here in the States, its an ask questions later and well sort it out later, right and civil liberties and all.